Carrier Claims Contact Info

As a Coyle Insurance Agency, Inc. personal insurance policy holder you have the option of contacting our agency at 845-268-7000 during business hours or directly contact your carrier below 24 hours a day.

Company Main Claims
Safeco Insurance Co. of America 800-332-3226
AARP Auto 877-805-9918
ACE 800-433-0385
Aetna Requires Member Login.
AIG Insurance Co. Personal: 800-562-2208
Business: 877-366-8423
American Modern 800-375-2075
Assurant Health 800-553-7654
Chartis 877-867-3783
Chubb 800-252-4670
CNA 877-262-2727
Condon & Skelley 800-257-9496
Encompass Insurance 800-588-7400
Fireman’s Fund 888-347-3428
Hagerty 800-922-4050
Hanover Insurance Co. Personal: 800-628-0250
Business: 800-628-0250
Harleysville Insurance Cos. 800-892-8877
Hartford Insurance Personal: 800-243-5860
Business: 800-327-3636
MetLife 800-638-5433
MetLife Auto 800-854-6011
New Jersey Manufacturers Ins. Co. 800-367-6564
Peerless Insurance 800-522-7152
Progressive Commercial 800-274-4499
Travelers Personal: 800-252-4633
Business: 800-238-6225
UnitedHealthcare 800-357-0978
Victor O. Schinnerer & Company Columbia, MD: 301-961-9800
Chevy Chase, MD: 301-961-9800
Houston, TX: 800-284-4747
Sacramento, CA: 916-286-5300
Zurich 800-987-3373